Pop Quiz: How to Get the Most Out of an Intelligent Water System

Water management plans can mitigate health and safety risks and help avoid potential lawsuits for negligence.
By James Dipping
September 27, 2022

Smart buildings use a wide range of existing technologies to facilitate the efficient and economical use of resources. They do this by collecting and sharing data between systems. And while your first thoughts may go to energy monitoring and HVAC controls, a growing awareness of intelligent domestic water systems is trending—and for good reason. Today’s building owners, operators and developers are adjusting to a new market environment in a post-pandemic world. Many are reexamining traditional functions of their facilities as tenants demand greater flexibility, connectivity, comfort, health and safety.

Integrating an intelligent domestic water system can have an impact on all those areas. The use of water management plans can mitigate health and safety risks and help avoid potential lawsuits for negligence. Here are some questions contractors need to be able to answer to get the most out of their intelligent water system.

It's all about conserving water, right?

According to recent reports from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), water use in commercial and institutional facilities (e.g., office buildings and hospitals) account for 17% of publicly supplied water in the United States. For these properties, restrooms, heating and cooling, and landscaping account for most of the use. Strategies to increase savings and efficiency include the following.

  • Harvesting rainwater, graywater (gently used water from bathroom sinks, showers, washing machines, etc.), and other non-potable water sources for outside irrigation and flushing applications.
  • Implementing energy-efficiency measures to reduce the need for building and equipment cooling and heating, which will reduce the amount of water required by these systems.
  • Installing more efficient fixtures (such as dual flush toilets, sensor-controlled faucets, etc.).

However, there’s a huge caveat on the third bullet point. Before rushing out to install a bunch of low-flow fixtures to save water, be advised that doing so in haste could be putting building occupants at risk. Today’s water pipe sizing practices are outdated and don’t consider the decreased volumes of water used by widespread low-flow fixtures. These devices can leave water in the pipes and increase building water age. Stagnant water in these systems can create an environment ideal for cultivating dangerous pathogens, including the bacterium responsible for Legionnaires’ disease.

When water was flowing at higher volumes thru the plumbing systems, the water purveyor’s primary and secondary disinfectants had the best chance at eliminating water-borne pathogens because the disinfectants used have a shelf life. The use of low-flow fixtures in conjunction with outdated water pipe sizing practices allow the disinfectants to expire before the water reaches your faucet. As a result, pathogens are given the opportunity to grow and multiply inside the building pipes.

The fixture unit method referenced in most plumbing codes to calculate water pipe size is based on the outdated Hunter’s Curve, developed back in the 1940s when plumbing fixtures were consuming water at much higher volumes. The plumbing engineering community must question why we are using a calculation method that fails to reflect the reality of today’s low-flow plumbing designs.

Building owners and managers should work with design engineers to correctly size the piping infrastructure of their facilities using tools like the Water Demand Calculator. While this tool is recognized for only certain building types in the Uniform Plumbing Code (UPC), it is a starting point for keeping water moving in buildings and recognizing that fixtures are flowing lower than they were in 1940. Only then can we reasonably recommend a holistic use of water-conserving fixtures. They are important but keeping buildings healthy is more important.

The short answer to your first quiz question is a qualified no. While conserving water by establishing an intelligent water system can be an important factor, it is much more than that. The health and safety of building occupants should be the prevailing motivation.

How does an intelligent water system reduce the risk of pathogens?

Legionella is a general category of bacterium all-too-commonly found in our water supplies. There are over 60 different species of bacterium, of which 25 are known to be implicated in human disease. There is one king of the species, Legionella pneumophila, that is responsible for approximately 90% of all infections. About one out of every 10 people diagnosed with Legionnaires’ disease will die due to complications from their illness. For those who get Legionnaires’ disease during a stay in a health care facility, the mortality rate climbs to about one out of every four.

Building owners and operators have good reason to be so concerned about Legionella as plumbing domestic water systems are the predominant source of the bacteria. If Legionella grows in a plumbing system, the bacteria can spread to humans via small droplets and/or vapor inhaled into the lungs. Common sources where these droplets are “made” include:

  • Showerheads and sink faucets;
  • Cooling towers;
  • Hot tubs;
  • Decorative fountains and water features;
  • Hot water tanks and heaters; and
  • Large, complex plumbing systems.

So how do the bacteria grow and spread? Water temperature, disinfectant residual, stagnation and quality, as well as pipe materials and other factors, can contribute to the development of Legionella pneumophila growth in the domestic water system. The larger and more complex the building is, the more challenging it is to maintain a healthy, balanced system. Complicating this further, the age, location, surrounding environment and incoming water quality can also have a significant impact on the development of Legionella bacteria.

Legionella bacteria have an ideal temperature range for growth, which also happens to be right in the sweet spot most building occupants favor for washing, bathing, showering or soaking in a hot tub. And if the building occupants are in a higher risk category, you may have to consider more options, such as supplemental disinfection to keep occupants safe.

ASRAE offers a guide, “Legionellosis: Risk Management for Building Water Systems,” which it describes as “essential for anyone involved in design, construction, installation, commissioning, operation, maintenance, and service of centralized building water systems and components.” Likewise, the U.S. Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) offers its “Toolkit: Developing a Water Management Program to Reduce Legionella Growth and Spread in Buildings.”

Why can’t I just crank up the temperature?

Treating water with high temperatures seems like a good answer to controlling the growth of pathogens like Legionella, but that approach could cause other problems. In the hospitality industry, the two biggest complaints are the lack of hot water and water that’s too hot. With an inability to confirm the water temperature in the supply piping to a guest room at the time such a complaint is lodged, hospitality establishments are forced to go along with whatever the guest claims, even when the complaint leads to a lawsuit.

If building management systems began incorporating more water monitoring, it would be possible to know exactly what the water temperature is in each pipe at any given time. Not only would this data enable buildings to confirm or dismiss water complaints, but it would ultimately give facilities the tools to improve systems performance and occupant health.

With an accurate picture of water temperatures as measured by sensors strategically placed throughout the building’s pipes, these levels can be properly adjusted to improve system performance, better reduce water pathogen growth and improve overall water quality. With this key building intelligence in hand, building engineers and managers would be much better equipped to take a proactive water management role and deliver safer, more hygienic water at the right temperature. The failure to monitor the temperature of domestic water systems outside the mechanical room can increase a building’s exposure to risk, litigation and hurt the bottom line.

What are the economic benefits?

In addition to making buildings safer, healthier, and more ecologically responsible, implementing a smart water system can have other positive impacts on a company’s balance sheet. Planning for the adoption of an intelligent system can uncover problems, such as previously undetected leaks or malfunctioning equipment, that may have otherwise gone unnoticed. More comprehensive metering can also identify areas to target reduced water use.

Establishing and communicating water conservation and efficiency measures can also position building owners, managers and companies as leaders helping to improve sustainability. Implementing best management practices for water efficiency can earn recognition for facility owners and managers in the green marketplace.

For a water management program to succeed, there should be a comprehensive strategic plan and vision in place. Understanding current water uses and systems allow building owners to develop a plan for greater water conservation, efficiency, management, and health and safety. Having clear objectives also helps organizations set priorities to allocate project funding to have the greatest impact.

by James Dipping
James Dipping, PE, CPD, ARCSA®AP, GPD, LEED AP BD+C, is the technical director of plumbing engineering for ESD, a leading global engineering firm specializing in mechanical, electrical, plumbing, fire protection, life safety, structural, and technology engineering. James has more than 25 years of experience in the plumbing design and construction industries. His main responsibilities include training development and engineering standardization, specification maintenance, design programming, project management and team leadership, client relations, and quality. James is a licensed Professional Engineer (PE), has spoken at American Society of Plumbing Engineers (ASPE) Tech Symposiums, and has published several articles in many industry magazines on various topics related to plumbing engineering.

Related stories

Closeout: The Water Is Wide
Harkers Island Bridge Replacement, Carteret County, North Carolina
Liftin' on a Prayer: Jon Bon Jovi's New Nashville Bar
By David McMillin
For DPR Construction, building Jon Bon Jovi’s new five-story bar in downtown Nashville meant working around 16,000 daily pedestrians, a packed entertainment schedule and a very tight footprint.
Great Expectations: Is Your 2024 What You Thought It Would Be?
By Grace Calengor
From interest rates slowing to AI implementation to lagging effects from 2022 and an impending election, can your construction company keep up with what 2024 has in store?

Follow us

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Stay in the know with the latest industry news, technology and our weekly features. Get early access to any CE events and webinars.